The events that transpired in the past week since the death of Minneapolis resident George Floyd at the hands of Minneapolis Police officers, (one who held his knee into Floyd’s neck for more than nine minutes, causing death by asphyxiation) were tragic enough. But what has followed appears to include not just violent action by domestic and foreign extremists groups, but police attacks on journalists there to cover the events.
The protests that began shortly after that incident have spread across multiple days, to 140 cities nationwide, including Denver. They are documented to have attracted not just peaceful protesters, but an element that includes right-wing extremist militias, including white supremacists.
The situation is volatile, and now it appears that journalists covering the protests have become a target of law enforcement. The Colorado Press Association (CPA) has reported that here in Colorado, as protests have occurred in downtown Denver over the death of Floyd, several journalists have been specifically targeted by law enforcement agents while covering the events.
The letter read, in part:
“It is inexcusable –and a violation of the journalists’ constitutional rights –for law enforcement officers to single them out for attack simply for doing their jobs in chronicling these events. If they are not interfering with officers, journalists have First Amendment and state constitutional rights to record and document the activities of police and protesters in public spaces.”
In response to these egregious violations, the CPA, Colorado Broadcasters Association, Colorado Freedom of Information Coalition and Colorado Pro Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists have written a letter to Colorado law enforcement and civic leaders expressing deep concern over this issue and the threat to constitutional rights.
Among the incidents against journalists:
- The Denver Post reported that photojournalist Hyoung Chang was struck twice Thursday night with pepper balls that cut his arm and shattered the press credential hanging around his neck. Chang said a Denver police officer fired two pepper balls directly at him.
- Denver Post reporter Elise Schmelzer, who was wearing a reflective vest with the word “Press” on it, said officers on Thursday fired at least one pepper ball at her feet.
- On Friday, a Denver 7 reporter wrote on Twitter that a station photographer was hit four times by “paint balls” fired by police.
- On Saturday, a 9NEWS reporter wrote on Twitter that state Capitol security officers fired “something” that hit his backpack “just after I went live with a large camera and light.” The reporter was wearing a 9NEWS hat. He found a yellow-and-black projectile at the spot where he was hit.
- On Saturday, a reporter for Denverite wrote on Twitter: “Cops shoved me after I showed them my press credentials and forced me to inhale choking gas.”
- On Saturday, a journalist wrote on Twitter that, while standing with photographers, an officer kicked a rolling chemical canister “sideways right into us. I took it full in the face…”
- On Sunday, another Denver Post reporter wrote on Twitter that he and a Denverite reporter, who was wearing a neon press vest, were ordered by an officer to move “toward an epic amount of tear gas … Cop points weapon right at us. We were forced back into the chaos and we both took a ton of gas to the face.”
- A New York Times reporter posted a photo of a contusion the Post reporter suffered after being hit with a projectile: “He screamed “Press” shortly before being hit as officers fired on protesters.”
Journalists, because of our role reporting the facts and truth of sometimes volatile events such as the recent protests, and controversial subjects, are often in harms way, whether physically threatened or verbally threatened. What is not expected is when they cover volatile events such as the demonstrations we have seen in Denver over the past several days, that law enforcement will single them out for attack for doing their jobs. It inexcusable –and a violation of the journalists’ First Amendment constitutional rights
In 2015, the”Colorado Legislature in 2015 enacted a law that specifically underscores the right to record police. If an officer “intentionally interferes” with a person’s lawful attempt to record an incident involving a peace officer, that person has a statutory right to recover damages from the law enforcement agency.
This is not the first recent case of Denver Police going after Colorado journalists. In 2018, then Colorado Independent Editor Susan Green (who is now an elected officer of the CPA) was wrongfully handcuffed and detained while photographing officers. Following that case, the Denver Police Department (DPD) agreed to get enhanced First Amendment training for its officers and paid $50,000 to settle the case.
Farschman confirmed this morning that a letter has been issued insisting upon the following protections of journalists, whose role is protected by the United States Constitution and is considered fundamental to the functioning of a democracy. Among the requests:
- These incidents of attacks on journalists are requested to be thoroughly investigated,
- That steps be taken to ensure officers respect the rights of journalists,
- That a joint press conference be held this week giving journalists the opportunity to ask questions,
- A joint task force is created to determine how best to avoid such incidents in the future.
The CPA has proposed a joint press conference be scheduled for later this week, for the media associations and Colorado journalists to ask questions of the DPD. At this point in time, that conference has not yet been set.
Ark Valley Voice is a member of the Colorado Press Association.